Treadmills: Love or Hate?

 I ask this because I had a very interesting conversation this week at the gym which made me stop and think. (In case you are wondering – this is not me, she is far too neat and tidy!)A woman on a treadmill (Original caption: &quo...

As always it started with general chit-chat. It then got interesting.

Do you run slower on a treadmill? That got me thinking and the answer is yes I think I do. Do you? I do a warm up program on the treadmill of 1 mile at a pace of about 10. This felt ok, not easy but not that hard either. When outside I find it hard to keep at a pace as slow as this – it always creeps up to 9 / 9.30 even when I am trying to run slowly. Then when I get into my running properly I seem to run faster than that but on the treadmill it never seems to be that easy – 8.30 pace seems really fast and a lot of effort.

Hmmm so then why? (these are just hypothesis).

It’s all in the rhythm? When outside you can subtly change your pace without realising it until you find the correct running rhythm for you on that day. (It amazes me how much my pace does change and when I think I am doing well it is not always the case!) On the treadmill your pace is determined by your brain and the computer. You put a speed in and the belt moves at that pace. That means that you have to run at a consistent pace the whole time. Although the treadmill does give you an even surface with no discrepancies in it.

It’s all in the brain? When you are outside there is much to distract you, from your surroundings, ensuring your foot falls on an even surface and even your route (where you are, where are you going next etc.) On the treadmill I do have a tv with a variety of channels to watch but I wouldn’t say that I ever got totally engrossed in any of them. My mind does not wander in the same way. All I focus on is the time and pace. This then means I put focus on how I feel now and how I might feel in another 5 minutes!!

I don’t have as much contact. When running up a hill (well slope here in the fens), when I need a bit of a boost I consciously push-off my back foot a bit harder. This obviously gives me a bit of momentum with which to keep my speed up. When I tried this on the treadmill I just wasn’t able to do it as the bit of the strap was moving and so wasn’t there long enough for me to get enough purchase.

You cannot have a bit of recovery. When I reach the top of a hill I can slow down a bit. Mentally I think that it doesn’t matter and give myself a bit of flack even if in reality I speed up quite quickly. On the treadmill unless you change the speed with the button your stay at the same pace. Whenever I slow down on a treadmill I don’t seem to be able to do it for a bit and it also seems to be slower than when outside.

What goes up must come down! (and hills all have a top) Well in real life that is true. I have a couple of ‘hills’ on my route. They are not long but steep for here. When embarking on them I have a definite end (the top) and after this there is a downhill ‘reward’ or recovery. When on a treadmill the ‘top’ is not visible – just a time so there is no real reward in making yourself go faster to reach the top. Also there is no downhill afterwards.

Am I making excuses or is there any truth in any of this? I would love to know. If it is all in my head then I need to change my mental state and move on! You may have guessed that I am not a particular fan of treadmills but I do see that they have their uses.

I am wondering if this would make it easier for me! I could catch up with all the news. (and be quite sick too I suspect!)treadmill workstation side view

As always to see what I have managed this week see here.

Advertisements

10 thoughts on “Treadmills: Love or Hate?

  1. Jan @ Handcrafted by Picto

    I’m a bit late getting around everyone at Handmade Monday but I thought I’d reply here rather than on your HM post, I love the hoop earrings but it’s not something I wear now (I used to back in the 70’s & 80’s) as for treadmills, the quick answer is…. I don’t run. I don’t mind them for walking and I do a fastish pace but not running, I agree with your point about seeing (or not) the top of the hill, it is a big boost when you can see you have reached a goal. Now I’m off to put my feet up, all this talk of running has tired me out :o)

    Jan x

    Reply
  2. fiddlyfingers

    Well that got me thinking!. I haven’t attended a gym for x amount of time now!! but used to go regularly although never went for a run outdoors. I always used to think I ran faster in the gym than I would outside, but that was only my perception maybe! Your final picture looks like a fantastic idea but and this is a big but … looks like ultimately, injury is very likely!!!!

    Reply
  3. fairweatherrunner

    I think I’m slower on the treadmill – it certainly feels like it becasue 5K feels like a life sentence! I hate the things with a passion. I’m always too hot and they give me leg ache proably becasue I run on my toes on them.

    Reply
  4. Karla

    Thanks for taking the time to comment at my place. 🙂
    First off, I’m impressed with your pace. I have never been able to run a mile at 10 speed on the treadmill, not even when I was fit. 8, sure but never 9 or 10. I clicked to check your mileage…..WOW! NICE! 🙂
    In regard to your post, I’ve always thought I run slower on the treadmill, but I blame it on the computer. Lol. I used to be able to run a mile in about 6 minutes 30 seconds, no problem but if I tried running a mile at the pace on the treadmill, I would die! There was no way. I could run a 5k in about 23 minutes, but on the treadmill….seems impossible. That’s why I plan to run my two miles outside, in hope that I am able to make time. lol. I just hope I don’t get shin splints…that would suck!

    Reply
    1. knitnrun4sanity Post author

      I have been running a long time now and built up slowly! I have a few half marathons coming up in the autumn so I am trying to just keep ticking over at the moment (that and it helps to keep me sane!)

      Reply
  5. Dakota Garibaldo

    Treadmills are great for toning down body fats, i always use the treadmill and it is great for cardio too. Wether you like walking or running, treadmill is great for exercise. .`'”. pay a visit to our new web page

    Reply
  6. Pingback: need for speed - The Aduke

I love to hear your thoughts and views.

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s